Empathy in Design: Measuring How Faces Make Places

Since 2015, Ragusa, Sicily has hosted FestiWall, an international art festival devoted to enhancing the public realm and improving citizen engagement with the modern section of an old city. Here are two views of a residential tower before and after FestiWall. Which one grabs your eye?

Screen Shot 2020-06-13 at 7.07.08 PM

Ragusa, Italy. Original image © FestiWall

We’ll guess you’re drawn to the one with the art at right. Running the image through biometric software predicts you’ll immediately focus on the man in the mural.

Screen Shot 2020-06-19 at 2.57.47 PM

Analysis with 3M VAS (Visual Attention Software) showing how people take things in.

And that’s what the analyses above shows. Note how the heat map, at left, which glows reddest where people look most, is on the face; the regions of interest diagram which aggregates predicted views, indicates 98% of viewers look straight at his head. And the gaze path, at right, shows people look first at the face, then briefly away before focusing right back on it again within the first 3-to-5 seconds.

And what happens if the building remains as is, untouched – blank? Not much! 

Screen Shot 2020-06-19 at 2.58.19 PM

Analysis with 3M VAS (Visual Attention Software)

The brain directs you to ignore the building. The grey wall simply cannot get attention. Note how the heat map, above left, shows up black, with views going around it; the regions of interest diagram, in center, makes focus shift to the sides, and the gaze path indicates people’s attention moves to the street below, never once settling on the tower, even though it’s directly centered before the viewer.

“The festival’s main goal is to open a dialogue between urban spaces and communities using city’s walls and street art as a medium.” say its founders Vincenzo Cascone and Antonio Sortino.This could be the first step towards a new perspective and a new development of the city.”

These striking efforts caught the attention of Caterina D’Amica and Isabel Gorham, students at the Boston Architectural College (BAC) who were interested in the way different murals engage the public, and which ones do so most effectively. They presented their findings, including the scenes above, last month.

“We compared and contrasted abstract FestiWall murals, with those with faces, with the original blank facades,” D’Amica and Gorham said. “The most successful murals, where attention is not dispersed, are the ones containing a face, a human form, and people in general.”

“Where the murals represent a person or a face, the attention is focused almost exclusively on the face or faces,” they reported, supporting the science on the face-bias in human perception. “Our brain is hardwired to find them; it’s a survival instinct.” Blank buildings, on the other hand, are “avoidant, and the eye does not pay attention to them, our vision diverted to edges, contrast, strong colors and light,” they added.

FestiWall murals are also a great example of empathy in design; the art that works best acknowledges first and foremost what we are built to see – a version of ourselves!  This hidden brain architecture directs our lives including our experience of buildings and our surroundings – whether we like it or not – and it always will!

It all goes to show how to best promote empathy in design: start with us, respecting the hidden traits that make us human.

Screen Shot 2020-06-21 at 11.04.20 AM
– – – –
Thanks to CommonEdge.org for reposting this article on their non-profit site July 1, 2020.
Thanks to Archdaily.com for reposting this article July 3, 2020.
Thanks to Archdaily.com for translating into Spanish and posting, July 7, 2020.
Thanks to ArchNewsNow.com for linking to this article on July 9, 2020.
This entry was posted in Architecture, City Planning, Design, Eye Tracking, Neuroscience, People-centric Design, STEM. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Empathy in Design: Measuring How Faces Make Places

  1. Denys says:

    Murals of this kind catch my attention. But nothing or something subtler would be much more pleasant. Every part of the building doesn’t have to shout out. The architect intends the side to blend in the surroundings, to be ignored and not distract. Blank space matters.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s